No I remember him well and probably saw more of him than most Albion fans, as he played longer at my hometown club Wycombe. All I'm saying is, when I think of the Albion strikers I've seen, I think he was undervalued and the club could and should have got more out of him.
With all due respect mate these appear to be some very rose-tinted lenses you're looking through
.
He was overweight and lethargic during his time at the Albion. Decent-ish cover for Hunt and Taylor considering the level we were at (3rd tier) but nothing more.
Wycombe were plying their trade in the 3rd tier also when under O'Neill, Garner partnered 36 year old Cyrille Regis upfront. Must have been quite something, and can see why you're enamoured.