I'd like to see us keep Ideye over Big Vic, as I think he did actually show signs of improvement under Pulis, and with Big Vic's injury problems and the fact he seems to have the heart the size of a pea, I feel Ideye would be worth the place in the squad more. There also something likeable about Ideye, he seems to have a likeable personality and good attitude.
That said, if we have Saido, Rondon and Lambert, one of the above need to be moved on and I think there is more chance of us getting a decent fee for Ideye than Vic.