If you "throw enough mud" or "heap enough praise" theory is alive and kicking still.
Personally, I'm happy to go along with Slavens team selections, as he is eminently more qualified and knows more about his players than any member of this forum.
But yes, I do often question a players commitment and performances and if a player isn't my "cup of tea" then I will offer what I consider to be a constructive and a fair and reasonable level of criticism and opinion on him. I also like to exercise a degree of giving others the "benefit of the doubt", which I know is a novelty these days and not always a popular view, particularly in football.
However, there is a constant undercurrent of obsession and fixation, not only of selected current players but which extends to former employees. Personally, I'm only interested in Albion and have, in most instances, little or no interest in what former employees do when they leave us.