Last summer J-Rod was in a strong position. There was interest from other clubs and he could have demanded to leave. I understand that he agreed to commit to the cause, and accept his 50% pay cut for his season rather than demand a move, on the basis that he would be allowed to leave for a fixed fee this summer. That fee does look too low, but it may well have been what was necessary to prevent him leaving last summer.
We probably had a choice - take it or leave it.
He hasn’t cost us the difference between £5m and what we could have allegedly got for him last summer, as we’d have had to replace him and his goals by signing a replacement. What it will have cost is the difference between £5m and his true current value, more like £10m, so a cost of £5m. Worth the gamble for his goals to get us up? Yes, in my view. He delivered on that front.
I don’t think he’s a great player at all, but he gave his all last season and his goals record is a fact. I don’t begrudge him a PL move now after his efforts of last season, and I feel the same with Hegazi. Dawson on the other hand sulked and let himself down.