Without doubt, as a player, Ronnie Allan, a firm favourite of mine as I was growing up, although diminutive in stature by today’s standards, was a giant of a centre forward in his era for Albion.
However, during a managerial career that spanned 16 years, I think he was not the “guru†of football and players that you make him out to be. With only two exceptions, Ronnie never stayed longer at a club more than 2 years, the exceptions being Wolves and Athletic Bilbao, where he was sacked by both clubs. In his other seven management roles he occupied during his career, twice managing Albion, he never stayed longer than 12 months, indeed about 6 months was the norm for him,I believe.
With regard to him leaving the Albion because he didn’t have a contract, he left Walsall to join Albion under similar circumstances. At the time he left, us after just 6 months, from what I was hearing at the time, he was offered a contract, but his demands could not be matched by the club and were not realistic.
His record at the Albion over two spells is Played 57, Won 18, Draw 18, Lost 21, Win Rate 36.84%
Big Ron’s record over two spells is Played 212, Won 85, Draw 68, Lost 49, Win Rate 40.09%
In the modern era of football, success is measured in tangibles e.g. stats and Big Ron’s stats are without doubt superior to Ronnie’s as was the style of football imo.
I also recall in his book “The Tony Brown Story†Bomber was not best pleased with Ronnie’s attitude towards him in trying to sell him when he didn’t want to leave, and the reason, Allen didn’t want Bomber to break his all time goal scoring record for the Albion. Bomber resisted the pressure and fortunately went on to break Ronnie’s record.
I agree he had an eye for a player, he recruited the likes of Derek Dougan and Mike Bailey, legends at the Molineux, but like all managers he wasn’t infallible. With regard to Cyril, didn’t Ronnie say he would pay the £5,000 transfer fee from his own pocket if Cyril didn’t turn out to be successful? Well, we all know how that turned out, an Albion legend, thank you Ronnie. I don’t think he made the most of the money we received from the sale of Robson and Moses to United, buying Martin Jol, who was probably the best buy, Zondervan, Mackenzie and King, not so. And don’t forget, he also inherited a decent side from John Giles.
At the end of the day, it's all about opinions, personal likes, dislikes and perceptions. For me, I much preferred Big Ron to Little Ron