http://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/revealed-best-worst-loan-players-8111001

Was just looking at this on the Birmingham mail website. Personally I think it's a bit harsh putting Thievy in the same bracket as Sinclair and El Ghanassy! He wasn't a complete success or we'd have signed him, but he wasn't the disaster those two were.

Who would you add to the list of good and bad loanees? I'd throw Fenton on the good list off the top of my head. You could make a case for Amalfitano although he went missing during the middle of the season.