Exactly, that NO winning promotion from league one, does not make you a player good enough for the championship, as random example off the top of my head Johnson Clark Harris I think his name was, who scored loads in the third tier for the posh and not so many above.
I totally agree with the forwarding planning part, but it doesn't mean we play players who aren't good enough yet just because they are one of our own.
We all want our own to do well with us, but we can't just play them if they aren't good enough yet.
Yes but you seem to be deeming him not good enough after one game against a premier league team.
I could also point out Ipswich has an example where they came up and kept the core of the league one team.
He was certainly no worse than Holgate.
I think in he cups we predominantly play a whole team of young ones and fringe players which gives us no insight has to wether a select few may excell in a team with more established first team
Plus to a certain extent centre halves and goalkeepers tend to mature and reach there peak a little later in there career
We might have to agree to disagree but I’m not writing him off yet in becoming good enough for us at our current level