As said above i shall be giving him a chance but i have a bad feeling about this, there is a lot of resentment towards staff at the club as it is, Irvine is going to have to work twice as hard just to be given a chance, we needed somebody who could unite everyone, i dont think this appointment has done that.
Irvines track record isnt outstanding and to say i am shocked is an understatement, the players seemed to lack respect for Pepe Mel and i cant see how this appointment is much different.
We have to give him a chance though ,I can only think he is appointed as he seems to be quite academy driven so he will try and introduce younger players and that we have a footballing director of football in Burton (if that makes any sense) so i would assume Irvines main duties will be coaching, lets hope he brings a lot of young hungry players to the club as well as promoting our own.
That said this is a huge risk, I have backed JP from Day one as think overall he has done a very good job, but initial thoughts this looks a strange appointment and a big risk (all appointments are to a certain extent) and if it goes wrong then he really has to question if he is the right man to to keep running the club.
Good luck Alan, you are going to need it.