To be fair, my criticism of Rondon's finishing is not based off his overall record, it was observations from seeing him miss clear chances. The difference for me is if Gayle is 12 yards out and pulls the trigger you think "this is a goal" before he hits it. It's not the same with rondon. There were far too many 'head in hands' moments for someone I could call 'lethal' in front of goal.
Don't get me wrong, I still liked him and was sad to see him go (would also love to see him alongside Gayle), I just disagree that he is this lethal striker who we somehow just used wrong. He's steady enough that youd expect ~10 goals a season from.